What Adds More Value: A Tub or Shower?

Undertaking a bathroom renovation is a significant undertaking that can be both challenging and rewarding. There are numerous factors that you need to consider to ensure that you achieve the best possible outcome and make your bathroom look fantastic.
A common question that homeowners have is whether adding a tub or a shower is a better investment for their property. Each option has its benefits and drawbacks, and the answer may differ based on several factors.
As bathroom remodeling experts in New Orleans or Jefferson Parish, we will help you explore this topic in detail and provide you with the necessary information to make an informed decision.

1. Assessing Functionality


If you need a space for relaxation and rejuvenation, a bathtub is the right choice!
After a long and hectic day, there is nothing quite like sinking into a warm bath to ease sore muscles and unwind. For families with young children, a bathtub is often seen as a necessity rather than a luxury. Bath time becomes an enjoyable ritual for parents and children alike, fostering bonding moments and ensuring proper hygiene.
Additionally, having a bathtub can be advantageous for pet owners, as it makes bathing furry companions more manageable and less messy.


Does convenience matter the most to you?
If so, showers offer a quick and efficient bathing solution!
A shower will allow you to freshen up quickly, making it an ideal choice for busy mornings or post-workout routines. You will find it a straightforward option if you prioritize practicality and simplicity in your daily life.
Modern showers have evolved beyond basic functionality to incorporate luxurious amenities that mimic spa experiences. From rainfall showerheads to body jets and steam options, there is no shortage of features to enhance your showering experience.
Moreover, from sleek glass enclosures to walk-in designs, the flexibility of shower installations allows you to maximize space and create a custom bathing experience tailored to your lifestyle.

2. Considering Space and Lifestyle


It is important to consider your bathroom space! The space required for a bathtub, including both the tub itself and the space needed to access it comfortably, can pose challenges in smaller bathrooms or compact layouts.
In tight quarters, fitting a bathtub may result in a cramped and cluttered appearance, detracting from the overall functionality and aesthetics of the space.
Are you someone who likes minimalist design principles or prefers a clean and uncluttered aesthetic?
If so, a bathtub may not align with their vision!
The bulkiness of traditional tubs can disrupt the sleek lines and open feel that characterize minimalist interiors.


Showers come in a range of sizes, shapes, and configurations, making them well-suited for smaller bathrooms or en-suites where space is at a premium. With clever design solutions such as corner showers, alcove installations, or even compact walk-in designs, you can maximize available space without sacrificing your comfort or style
Also, if you are looking for a quick and efficient bathing solution that allows you to freshen up quickly without the time-consuming process of filling and draining a tub, a shower is ideal for you!
Additionally, features such as low-threshold entryways, grab bars, and built-in seating can enhance safety and accessibility, catering to a diverse range of users and age groups.

3. Evaluating Market Trends


Historically, having at least one bathtub in a home was considered a must-have for maximizing resale value. This is so because potential buyers often viewed bathtubs as symbols of luxury and relaxation, associating them with spa-like experiences and indulgent self-care routines.
On the other hand, urbanization and the rise of busy professional lifestyles have led to a growing preference for convenience and efficiency in daily routines. As a result, many homeowners, particularly in densely populated urban areas, are prioritizing showers over bathtubs.


Many homebuyers are drawn to sleek glass enclosures, spacious shower stalls, and high-end fixtures that elevate the bathing experience to new heights of comfort and style!
To ensure such a bathing experience, you can choose walk-in showers with frameless glass doors that create a sense of openness and airiness, enhancing the overall aesthetic appeal of the bathroom.
An important consideration is that as the population ages, there is a growing demand for bathroom features that accommodate mobility challenges and promote independent living. To cater to this need, you can also go for curbless showers with level-entry thresholds that eliminate tripping hazards and make it easier for people with limited mobility to enter and exit safely.

4. Factoring in Maintenance and Upkeep


If you have bathtubs, they will require you to provide regular cleaning to prevent the buildup of grime, soap scum, and mildew. The enclosed space of a tub can make it more prone to moisture retention, creating an ideal environment for mold and mildew growth.
Moreover, bathtubs may require periodic maintenance and repairs to address issues such as chips, cracks, or worn finishes. So, repairing or refinishing a damaged tub can be a costly and time-consuming task for you, involving specialized equipment and expertise.


Showers are generally easier to clean and maintain compared to bathtubs, especially if equipped with low-maintenance materials such as tile or acrylic surrounds. Smooth, non-porous surfaces are less susceptible to mold and mildew growth and can be cleaned with simple household cleaners and a sponge or cloth.
Your routine maintenance tasks for showers typically involve cleaning the grout between tiles, replacing worn or deteriorated caulking around seams and joints, and occasionally descaling showerheads to remove mineral deposits.

What do you Consider- a Bathtub or a Shower?

Ultimately, the decision between a tub and a shower is a deeply personal one, influenced by individual lifestyle preferences, family dynamics, and design aesthetics.
Whether you prioritize relaxation and luxury or value convenience and functionality, the key is to create a bathing space that reflects your unique needs and enhances your overall well-being.

Key Takeaways

So, what adds more value: a tub or a shower?
The answer isn’t black and white!
While traditional wisdom suggests that a bathtub adds more value to a home, modern trends, and lifestyle preferences indicate a growing preference for showers. Ultimately, the best choice depends on your specific needs, available space, and target market if you’re considering resale value.
Whether you opt for a luxurious soaking tub or a sleek walk-in shower, investing in a well-designed and functional bathroom can enhance your home’s overall appeal and comfort.
Forbathroom remodeling in New Orleans and Jefferson Parish, ELM Construction Group is a well-established option. We offer a range of services including custom bathroom vanities, replacement tubs, bath conversions, new bathroom construction, as well as small and half bathroom remodeling.
For more information or to request a free bathroom remodeling estimate, you can contact ELM Construction Group directly at504-478-7865 or via email at elmconstructiongroup@gmail.com
Scroll to Top